法政匯思: 法律未必能矯正一切不公義TVBNOW 含有熱門話題,最新最快電視,軟體,遊戲,電影,動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。3 [4 l& f3 u- T% ]8 W. K+ n
& k+ @# [6 y- k2 s- ]1 v
公仔箱論壇+ L$ h" [7 V$ H9 b' f
; B6 P6 \6 F8 xtvb now,tvbnow,bttvb ; J$ V% v- f }4 ]( C0 }$ h5 wTVBNOW 含有熱門話題,最新最快電視,軟體,遊戲,電影,動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。8 f4 _8 O2 Q: T9 ]! G! F 【《法政匯思》短評:關於近日一個七旬長者被判入獄四個月的案件】 4 ~5 M$ p- h# A- v: ~0 ]2 ptvb now,tvbnow,bttvbTHE PROGRESSIVE LAWYERS GROUP'S SHORT COMMENTARY REGARDING A RECENT CASE WHERE AN ELDERLY PERSON IN HIS SEVENTIES WAS SENTENCED TO FOUR MONTHS' IMPRISONMENT; p b, \9 `$ H9 Y: }% b
8 v$ W& C/ y. p' t' ?公仔箱論壇根據近日傳媒報道,一名七旬患有心臟病長者,因為希望能自力更生去照顧自己及其妻子,在過往六年期間用在深圳買回來把自己年齡報得年輕一點的「身分證」來獲聘用為保安員。在這段時間,他的工作表現良好,曾經因此收到警察書面上的嘉許。 ) h2 v* K7 g3 T* \TVBNOW 含有熱門話題,最新最快電視,軟體,遊戲,電影,動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。tvb now,tvbnow,bttvb- E' h# \4 z7 Q s( [3 b
但他用的「身分證」的非真實性最終被發現,失去工作之餘亦就此被刑事起訴。長者最終在上星期四被判入獄四個月。社會人士就這案件量刑的對與錯議論紛紛。單憑近日的報導,要嘗試評論這案件的量刑實在不容易。我們只能十分概括地說,「欺騙金錢利益」的確是會被法庭視為嚴重的刑事罪行,而這類案件在定罪後被判入獄亦是常見的。就此,我們呼籲所有在評論這案件對或錯的人士能保持克制,避免對個別司法人員作出謾罵或沒有根據的攻擊。TVBNOW 含有熱門話題,最新最快電視,軟體,遊戲,電影,動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。1 x9 [$ e- {+ w2 |0 `! c( y2 k' [
4 w# ~7 _/ ]4 a: X! n. D/ v言歸正傳,或許這個慘案所反映的,就是法律未必是適合用來去處理及矯正社會上一切不公義的工具。法律始終是根據一些大原則去執行,而這些原則亦很難去兼顧所有各式各樣的情況及案件。這案件所帶出來的,反而是一些更深層次的社會問題。當我們的壽命越長、越有能力工作到一個較大的年紀時,為何我們的就業市場就偏偏越來越排斥年紀較大的人士?當我們的社會應該是富裕時,為何貧困的長者不被賦予機會去分享這富裕的果實,而是要為了維持生計,想盡辦法繼續嘗試找低薪但亦艱辛的工作?當一個社會的文明與否是在於我們怎樣對待弱勢社群時,為何我們締造了一個「凡是拿福利的人都是懶人」的風氣,使弱勢社群受壓,覺得受到任何資助就等同被剝削尊嚴?公仔箱論壇1 M6 r5 R; F5 s2 I( D
tvb now,tvbnow,bttvb2 C5 e2 j8 o& [' c a+ S
就讓我們法律界及其他專業人士從今次及類似事件能體會到,我們不是因為所謂「讀多些書」,就甚麼都認識、甚麼都能高高在上地「教」他人應該怎樣過他們的生活。我們需要的,是多一份謙卑、多一份同理心、多一份愛,好好地向我們的弱勢社群學習、使他們得到應有的尊重。 8 R8 Y, N& [& j0 F/ V5.39.217.77:8898, k" y9 d1 T+ t% R) n7 r
法政匯思/ l: p, @+ e: E$ K: w/ o
2015年4月21日 - l( Z3 G/ I o S: u 4 K7 W% Y* R/ c6 }; m; [tvb now,tvbnow,bttvb% F8 H* F7 q! Z
According to recent press reports, an elderly person in his seventies with a history of heart problems had in the past 6 years used forged ID cards he purchased in Shenzhen which showed him to be younger than he actually was, so that he could continue to be employed as a security guard to support himself and his wife, without not relying on welfare. His work performance was good during the relevant period and he had received written commendations from the Police.公仔箱論壇1 _ X. w8 v. i) S- [" u& D
5.39.217.77:8898( E H, t+ d: |' C6 S/ K' M
However, the fact that his identity card was not genuine was eventually discovered. The elderly lost his job and was prosecuted, and he was sentenced to 4 months’ imprisonment last Thurday. The correctness or otherwise of the decision has led to much discussion among members of the public. We are not in a position to comment on the sentence in this case solely based on the facts as stated in the recent reports. We can only note generally that obtaining a monetary advantage by deception is considered as a serious offence by the Court, and it is common for those convicted of such an offence to be sentenced to imprisonment. As such, we call on everyone who is commenting on the correctness or otherwise of the decision to exercise restraint and refrain from making abusive or unfounded attacks on individual judges.TVBNOW 含有熱門話題,最新最快電視,軟體,遊戲,電影,動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。; ]4 O- w' f- q! K5 W$ d
\! O( |- b! G) t- e: |. b公仔箱論壇Returning to the case itself, it is perhaps the case that this tragic matter demonstrates that the law may at times not be an appropriate tool to deal with or rectify all injustices in the society. The law is enforced by the application of certain general principles, and it is difficult for such principles to seek to cater for every single scenario and case. This case has in fact raised some deeper social issues. Whilst we now have longer life expectancy and are capable to remain in work longer, why does the labour market increasingly shut out these elderly workers? In an affluent society like Hong Kong, why are those elderly citizens who are living in poverty not entitled to share the fruits of our success, but are instead forced to seek tough but low-paying jobs in order to support themselves? When a society's civility is measured by how it treats its weakest members, why are we stigmatising all welfare recipients as the “lazy poor”? This makes the social vulnerable groups feel pressured into thinking that receiving welfare is somehow undignified.公仔箱論壇: O) {% z+ b4 ?9 s' s
# m" g- D. r1 E- w& t) {, ?We in the legal profession and other professions should learn from this incident and other similar incidents that our so-called better education does not mean we know everything and can see fit to "teach" others how they should live their lives. What we need is to demonstrate more humility, empathy and love towards the vulnerable in society, to learn from them and let them have the respect and dignity they deserve. 6 q7 @9 B2 w. w+ j$ htvb now,tvbnow,bttvb& v4 \! c% f @6 p9 Q3 p
Progressive Lawyers Group5.39.217.77:8898' G$ X" k! u/ [ f9 L
23 April 2015作者: felicity2010 時間: 2015-4-23 12:14 PM
張震遠 判囚六星期 准保釋候上訴TVBNOW 含有熱門話題,最新最快電視,軟體,遊戲,電影,動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。: _2 U. N8 `+ }, [! w
$ C% T0 i4 B, V( Y/ o- A7 |9 P 6 u3 ~ z0 n0 wtvb now,tvbnow,bttvb 3 d% G$ i, Q4 G# h+ I5.39.217.77:8898 2 u) _9 J6 y2 n. t$ [7 B公仔箱論壇【早上11時22分更新報道和標題,補充法官准許保釋和判刑內容。】7 @- l5 c6 X k( F
% N" X. b8 f8 h# L: |! V; D
前行會成員及前商交所主席張震遠,因拖欠員工薪金約34萬,今早於九龍城裁判法院被判囚6星期,他隨即申請保釋等候上訴,獲法庭批准,准以現金5000元保釋等候上訴,期間不准離港,以及要交出所有旅遊證件。張震遠約11時許離開法院,面帶微笑,但沒回應記者問題。5.39.217.77:8898/ C+ q g0 z, r1 X) T
TVBNOW 含有熱門話題,最新最快電視,軟體,遊戲,電影,動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。 C: J! H5 l# w
裁判官判刑時表示,張震遠被起訴後,一直住在淺灣寓所,上月底搬往跑馬地月租達16萬元的單位,租金雖由妻子支付,但反映他有其他方法籌錢,卻沒將還錢給員工放在優先位置,認為他沒悔意,故不適合判處社會服務令或緩刑。 + b* e0 w/ t- ]. M7 @5.39.217.77:8898# y# J% n1 c- K: N; E
57歲的張震遠,被控拖欠商交所前高級企業傳訊經理馬兆龍,在2013年5月至8月的薪金,並且沒有依照勞資審裁處頒令,在限期內支付34萬元欠薪。他在上月審訊時承認「沒有在到期日內支付欠薪」及「沒有根據判令支付款項」兩條控罪。另外,張震遠上星期因欠債超過1.2億元,已被法庭頒令破產。TVBNOW 含有熱門話題,最新最快電視,軟體,遊戲,電影,動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。. A6 \0 l; S; }3 X" v# c$ l0 P) z0 D
, I3 d" g& k, c- a* Z4 D ) r% [% I/ v) y: CTVBNOW 含有熱門話題,最新最快電視,軟體,遊戲,電影,動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。/ _1 z* g6 `& |: y# l+ f
「一萬個人出一分力,比一個人出一萬更有意義。」網民自發向施伯伯施婆婆送上的關心,在法官冰冷無情的鐵面上,灑下溫暖情味。 : o( i9 @! G9 D9 ?: M, j. TTVBNOW 含有熱門話題,最新最快電視,軟體,遊戲,電影,動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。3 v# B% V. |6 W% E( J
施伯伯為自力更新不想申領綜援,用假身份證報細年齡做保安賺取低微生活費,承認以欺騙手段取得金錢利益及管有虛假文書等七罪,被判監4個月。TVBNOW 含有熱門話題,最新最快電視,軟體,遊戲,電影,動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。3 R( }# d' j4 x: q$ C% l% }
TVBNOW 含有熱門話題,最新最快電視,軟體,遊戲,電影,動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。+ a" s/ ]; y. w
與被告施教仁相依為命的妻子得知判刑後曾說:「為甚麼法官只講法不講情,一點沒有人性。」! H R) v' K- G9 M8 e: j, @
, a5 O8 \0 V3 w5.39.217.77:8898網民為表對施伯伯施婆婆的關愛,對法官判詞的不滿,紛紛向施婆婆送上心意卡、超市禮劵及一人上限一百元的款項。代為收集的Benson Tsang 表示迄今已收到370位現實世界的朋友的現金;心意卡及慰問信也收到142封。這封寫在封底的讓他特別感動。TVBNOW 含有熱門話題,最新最快電視,軟體,遊戲,電影,動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。& A' `" `! G! p$ W9 n1 n- J1 a' f
公仔箱論壇- M* D n: d: {+ E8 B3 E, |
相關新聞:「想靠自己,不靠綜援」,裁判官直言「唔值得同情」(1)、(2)5.39.217.77:8898& n' e; m) ^% `+ L$ a