公仔箱論壇 - Powered by Discuz! Board

標題: [問題] 想买一支镜头，不知道选那一支好 [打印本頁]

作者: pppmmm 時間: 2011-1-4 12:32 AM 標題: 想买一支镜头，不知道选那一支好

各们前辈你们好，我想从下列四款镜头选一支，现在只有一支 Canon EF 24-105mm 镜头:

EF 28-300mm f/3.5-5.6L IS USM
EF 70-200mm f/2.8L IS II USM
EF 16-35mm f/2.8L II USM
EF 24-70mm f/2.8L USM

本人主要是用来旅行拍照用的，因本身那支觉得边角位置拍得有点不太清楚。谢谢！！

作者: leekl80 時間: 2011-1-4 12:39 AM

For me I will choose 70-200 and 24-70 to fit full frame body... if crop frame, i will get 16-35 and 70-200... why i never choose 28-300 because i don't like F/3.5-5.6...

作者: pppmmm 時間: 2011-1-4 01:13 AM

Thank you for your suggestion. But my budget is able to afford one len, which one would you like to pick.

作者: leekl80 時間: 2011-1-4 01:29 AM

If I am using full frame, i will chose 24-70, crop frame will go for 16-35.
Reason: 24 x 1.6 = 38.4 or 24 x 1.3 = 31.2.. I dun think is enough wide for traveling used. Unless I have another wide angle lens, then I will go for 70-200... This is a very good lens and I own one in my bag...

作者: pppmmm 時間: 2011-1-4 01:58 AM

Actually, I am using 5D II, and 24-105mm is the only len that I have. In your suggestion, I'm better go for 24-70mm instead of 70-200mm. Am I understand right.

作者: leekl80 時間: 2011-1-4 02:13 AM

My suggestion is go for 16-35 since you own 24-105... take some range that you don't own right now...

作者: pppmmm 時間: 2011-1-4 02:16 AM

Thank you very much

作者: ssal 時間: 2011-1-4 11:48 AM

You basically listed the choice of three separate groups of lenses. The first two are telezoom, the third is a telewide and the fourth is a day-to-day general purpose. I would say they are not the choice of one or other. If budget allows, you should, or you don't mind having one from each group.

But you said you can afford only one for general purpose, then the 24-105 you have is good enough. The 24-70 f/2.8 is of higher quality, but it is twice as expensive and heavy. The 70mm max. zoom is a little short sometimes.

So, if you want to have just one, you should not waste your money. You just have to accept that the bigger the multiple of optical zoom, the worse the quality at the max. and min. of the zoom range.

When you can afford it, then go with the 24-70, and 70-200, both f/2.8. I think this is the most popular combination.

I shoot Nikon full frame and I have been using the 35-70mm f/2.8D for a long time before I added the 80-200mm f/2.8 and 20mm f/2.8 later. I also have a prime portrait lens (105mm f/2.0 DC). I personally don't like multi-aperture lenses. When I was shooting cropped frame, I had a 17-55mm f/2.8. It was a very good quality lens, but it was very heavy.

作者: waiwai1028 時間: 2011-1-4 09:32 PM

你有24-105 ~
不如買支Y用~

16-35~ OR 70-200

作者: chowold2 時間: 2011-1-4 11:50 PM

I am using 24-70 and 70-200mm. suppose those are the best lens in your list and fit you right. But you own the 24-105 already, you have no choice( only buy the additional 70-200). Or you can sell your 24-105( Look like you don't like it that much) and trade for the 24-70mm

作者: pppmmm 時間: 2011-1-5 04:00 AM

If my budget is only able to afford one len only, will you consider 28-300mm f3.5-5.6 len for my travelling purpose. Or let's go for 70-200mm f2.8 without any hesitation.

作者: pppmmm 時間: 2011-1-7 12:12 AM

Would you please tell me where can I trade my len, and which store is the lowest price compare to others. Thank you very much.

作者: DUKE77GO 時間: 2011-1-7 03:13 AM

你用半幅机还是全幅机呢？其实16-35+70-200买晒就够你暂时用了

作者: alex0310 時間: 2011-1-7 10:24 PM

以焦段來看
16-35這隻重覆性最少

作者: pppmmm 時間: 2011-1-8 04:39 AM

我是用全幅机的 13# DUKE77GO

作者: chowold2 時間: 2011-1-10 02:37 AM

If my budget is only able to afford one len only, will you consider 28-300mm f3.5-5.6 len for my travelling purpose. Or let's go for 70-200mm f2.8 without any hesitation.
pppmmm 發表於 2011-1-5 04:00 AM

You should just buy another 70-200mm. The 24-105mm is not the best lens for full frame camera but really a not too bad lens.
If you really want to trade your lens, try the adorama.com. I did the trade there before.That is a American site, they sell and buy the used lens. If you are not living there, it is a little trouble to do the trade.

作者: 精彩每天 時間: 2011-1-15 10:14 AM

选EF 28-300mm f/3.5-5.6L IS USM。

作者: lovebebe 時間: 2011-1-15 10:41 PM

16-35啦

作者: lawken1 時間: 2011-1-17 01:04 PM

太漂亮了！

作者: Kenzkenz 時間: 2011-1-20 02:45 AM

小弟認為先確定你影相既取向~
如果鍾意影遠既,一定係EF 70-200mm f/2.8L IS II USM OR EF 70-200mm f/4L IS USM
如果影人像同境多就選大光圈而變焦小既鏡~如EF 24-70mm f/2.8L USM or EF 16-35mm f/2.8L II USM
最緊要唔同鏡都有佢自已既長處~你要知道你想要乜先~!^^

作者: know53 時間: 2011-3-8 09:22 PM

學習了解谢谢分享!

作者: phoung 時間: 2011-3-10 09:31 AM

thanks

作者: phoung 時間: 2011-3-10 09:41 AM

請教前輩 28x300mmf3.5~5.6 及70x300mm 有何分別

作者: applecobi 時間: 2011-3-11 09:57 AM

我會建議EF 16-35mm f/2.8L II USM,
這樣影風景有更佳角度

作者: sotongia88 時間: 2011-3-16 02:38 AM

谢谢楼主分享好东西～！！！希望还有更好的分享～！！！

作者: sotongia88 時間: 2011-3-16 02:39 AM

谢谢楼主分享好东西～！！！希望还有更好的分享～！！！

作者: iveho 時間: 2011-5-16 08:00 PM

如果經濟上許可，就全部買晒啦…正所謂千難買心頭好…支持你！

作者: second5cm 時間: 2011-5-19 10:32 AM

如果是全幅机，是為了旅行用，那麼我建議買　EF 16-35mm f/2.8L II USM（635g），加一支EF 70-300mm f/4-5.6 IS USM（630g），這兩支的價格加起來也不及一支EF 70-200mm f/2.8L IS II USM（1.49kg）昂貴，而最重要的是注意EF 70-200mm f/2.8L IS II USM的重量，如果不是專業拍攝的，跟本便不想把它帶上街。旅行咩，最重要是要輕便。

歡迎光臨公仔箱論壇 (http://5.39.217.77:8898/)