8867878

係咁噶喇.. 拍民初時期d電視劇都係咁一樣噶!!

eie319

tvb should go to mainland to film this series

kidhitomi

5楼讲得好
, S/ R1 E) _* e楼主你咁样不如唔好睇了( W5 {4 P8 Z8 V. F9 K( y/ \5 Q
TVB拍噶剧集比较好睇，我会支持TVB 希望越拍越好, W' N( K# D, v% {- E; I
全中国最钟意噶电视台就得TVB同埋ATV
# v! p# O; \7 q# g公仔箱論壇其它都係垃圾

chriscyj

个人觉得，看剧是需要看目的在哪儿~鉴于TVB的聚集多以轻松减压为主，还是不要太过要求严谨，一旦严谨如国内电视剧，那又会有多少人愿意拿来消遣时间呢？诸如《江山风雨情》等述说明朝历史的剧，国内拍得尊重历史，严肃，而且豪华，但又有多少人留意呢？还是不要去深究TVB究竟拍了一个怎样的洪武三十二年，姑且当朱棣，朱允炆等是某本小说的主人翁就作罢吧，毕竟戏剧系源于生活，高5高于生活，见仁见智啦~

heinous

TVB的道具部门N年都5更新啦
3 s% d' c) h; |3 c6 O5.39.217.77:8898我最记得就是有个帖子贴出不同的电视剧里同样的衣服~~~

hing19

thanks for your sharing:>:>:>:>:>:>$ M. S, D# K' p' J6 ~
it just a film:>:>:>:>

hongkongbt

樓主不適合看香港電視劇, 韓劇, 甚至台劇7 s9 H3 X7 \4 N+ ~
樓主適合看大陸的電視劇, 單是說兵馬, 就真的可以找來幾千幾萬的了5.39.217.77:8898  T! ^7 O& f4 m( Q) c1 a/ }& P. x

) Y( x# I. c9 T( k" X  A! Y0 [3 T% h5.39.217.77:8898樓主應該很少看韓劇, 韓劇的古代景也是來來去去都是那些
) u# G& l1 }/ u: t+ C& C+ @! a3 qTVBNOW 含有熱門話題，最新最快電視，軟體，遊戲，電影，動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。TVB 拍古裝 (要有建築物), 如果不是在電視城,  ...5.39.217.77:8898& P8 h) Q  ?) g5 J  W
superbasara 發表於 2011-4-8 05:29 AM

2 }! ]$ k2 v# D: H5 ~, B
5.39.217.77:8898* q7 D2 W, e+ \2 ~, |
我有點懷疑你是TVB 派來的
1 {# P- b. }  N; tTVBNOW 含有熱門話題，最新最快電視，軟體，遊戲，電影，動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。見你有批評TVB 但到最後還是幫TVB 解釋了很多.....tvb now,tvbnow,bttvb9 U* j8 P$ Q+ @
) x6 F/ r7 q/ y7 W/ ^
你說 "通常, TVB 會抄的都是人物 setting , 枝節就沒有抄很多"
" l+ S, s+ y7 S我真的笑了....難道用電腦scan 犯人個腦不是抄足嗎? 那個什麼能穿越時空的電話不是抄足嗎? 還有不少例子我也沒時間詳述....
$ M( `: U+ |  N7 K+ k% etvb now,tvbnow,bttvb這些不是人物 setting 吧?  D  Y  h7 w$ @9 X! `0 N
公仔箱論壇. X: C9 t6 v3 Q$ ^1 x* k
還有 你說 "有些人除了看漫畫, 看動畫, 還看真人版, 其實故事全部一樣, 主角全部一樣, 為什麼可以看這麼多次呢?"
, z  \, D7 }  ^. U& L- O公仔箱論壇日本漫畫改篇的劇集 是多, 但是因為漫畫本身有質素, 就算改篇成劇集也同樣吸引而質素绝對有保證, 另外,他們是講明由漫畫改篇的.......這是低質素兼抄襲的TVB劇集 所不能相比的....
  f( z% V& Z0 S8 n* `8 \. K- H1 L6 i. p
"TVB 拍的是電視劇, 不是歷史劇 (紀錄片那些), 也不是拍高質素的電影
$ C) T  ?/ j4 V% j) f/ K5 {0 a( K很多人看劇集是當娛樂, 所以他們不會吹毛求疵, 雞蛋裡挑骨頭
! b' D7 o0 w( C; u4 j有些人喜歡看穿崩, 找錯處
4 |' Y4 |) i5 P* `% V+ V. a' @* |" f有些人喜歡為批評而批評公仔箱論壇3 Q2 G0 J6 Y& }
從來都是那一句, 不喜歡看的就千萬不要看, 為難自己"
& F, J0 k3 U0 ~6 e7 M" Y0 @4 `5 _7 U4 ^+ n8 y% |* a. }
這段我不太同意, 有誰說過劇集 不需要高質素? 外國的劇集是有質素的.....難道 X-files 、ER 不是電視劇?5.39.217.77:88981 T9 [, B6 r$ `3 I% z5 W- Y
我不承認我是在雞蛋裡挑骨頭, 因為TVB 拍的是電視劇並不是"雞蛋".......' E# D" j; d8 w6 X
所謂的 "雞蛋" 該是指X-files 、ER 這些高質素的電視劇TVBNOW 含有熱門話題，最新最快電視，軟體，遊戲，電影，動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。  d2 u% t- D0 }. w
"有些人喜歡看穿崩, 找錯處".....是, 我是這種人, 但TVB劇集的穿崩/錯處實在多的不用找, 就算見到也不必興奮.....
9 C, `4 }/ s7 ^9 {7 F' ~- o2 m
8 b9 Y. ^/ O! \# j; wtvb now,tvbnow,bttvb"不喜歡看的就千萬不要看, 為難自己" 這是我唯一認同的.....只有怪香港太细, 太少電視臺, 那些收費電視臺又太垃圾......於晚飯這個黄金時間電視節目的選擇實在太少5.39.217.77:8898* H' x$ G- z5 m7 g& P
TVB 的電視劇實在差, 但還是比ATV 的外購倉底劇、有線的垃圾節目好少許......J2 的旅遊節目 和 明珠台的節目 也是可以的, 所以我也不會太為難自己去看TVB 的電視劇.....5.39.217.77:88988 K  L" F; s. T$ n: E
. f" r. K7 d) Z" T4 K
但我不說出來的話.....TVB 的電視劇只會越來越差.....觀眾也就繼續逆來順受.....

mrfusion

TVB does not need improvement just like Microsoft does not need improvement, TVB basically monopolised the TV industry in HK, and it is actually producing something, it is already 1000 times better then its closest and only competitor ATV, which doesn't make anything, 90% of what is shows are old series or purchased.
& ]2 [) O7 S/ c! S& a8 fTVBNOW 含有熱門話題，最新最快電視，軟體，遊戲，電影，動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。
7 m0 p, \0 x- c* E2 S) o* f/ W. u5.39.217.77:8898TVB only has HK ads, and it only has as much money as the commercial income gives them, HK audiences are limited, unlike American Series, unlike Taiwan series, it has limited budget. Hollywood can model a whole cities, TVB don't have those money.  tvb now,tvbnow,bttvb' `% n5 {# n) s, p9 y/ V" [

! G! ]# T0 g% s5 y  C% utvb now,tvbnow,bttvbObviously, majoritry of its audience doesn't mind as it still deliver 30+ points in viewerships. Where the best ATV do is 2 points.   }' \# ?$ d8 f- x8 X
  S5 n1 @: [4 F3 L1 L9 R# j
Korean / Japanese movies looks good because they are different, not because it is better. tvb now,tvbnow,bttvb, D! V# E! k& ]+ h

/ k+ K' W' F9 R2 o% J公仔箱論壇a lot of the mainlander/external movies are also shit as it drag things on for too long.

妍霜

TVBNOW 含有熱門話題，最新最快電視，軟體，遊戲，電影，動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。0 L1 Y2 y0 e, F  L

) E/ O2 R; f% @  _( d: g4 ~香港有多大呢,我想大家都心中有數..而且播放出來給的也是香港的小市民看,你看mytv 就知道,其他地方的人特地跑去看其電視台的最近播放也只是額外罷了(海發劇/綜藝節目不算)..而且收入來源也不多公仔箱論壇7 K( `) }0 g6 ^
資金成本造就很多限制...而且演員,幕後的工作人員也要吃飯的吧... Y  U$ X( }/ o6 r
另外,如秋官所說...電視機的揸fit人是一般的主婦,而普羅大眾在一天忙碌下來..要的也是娛樂,輕鬆一下罷了...又會多少探究歷史怎樣怎樣,背景道具,音樂怎樣怎樣來較真呢..而且呀是年輕一輩通過上網呀什麼的其他資訊渠道才看的比較多外語,什至華語劇,這樣才有所說的對比是抄呀什麼的...試問橋段這玩意也不過大同小二,好似小說不也是麼0 P: d5 y- n$ e& M
而且以全世界來算,有多少國家,城市以及地方是有自己出產的電視節目...不要說比較大通用一點的華語,英語,西班牙,法語,還有一些其他的,以東南亞為例的,也有很多如尼泊爾語,柬埔寨語,印尼語,印度語,馬拉語等等
+ j2 U7 v" Y7 A7 ~tvb now,tvbnow,bttvb
+ o; J8 ]! o' T* h/ p5 V% gTVBNOW 含有熱門話題，最新最快電視，軟體，遊戲，電影，動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。你說無記的劇是抄襲別人的,你又如何知你說的外語劇沒有抄襲別人的呢..

jeffchan928

That's ok!

huit

5.39.217.77:8898/ }+ q+ o; _% n) H. Z) g
5.39.217.77:8898$ q: I5 V: ?1 _; ]
While it's true that TVB may not have the same resources and the kind of budget to achieve the same production values as overseas (particularly Western) programmes, resulting in the same film sets, soundstages and props being used over and over again, that's excusable, as long as the production team actually took their jobs seriously instead of churning out the same rehashed crap over and over again.
0 k+ o+ u1 U5 v3 J6 n2 W8 B0 n+ V
There are a few things that don't cost extra $$$ you can do well - try writing a better script for once that doesn't insult the viewers' intelligence (ok obviously that is dependent upon the average level of intelligence of the viewers), stop sticking to a formula, and stop adding absurd plot twists just to move the story along. Oh and spare us those longwinded, tear-jerking scenes, most of the time they just serve to irritate the audience "get over it already" - they're hard on both the actors and viewers alikeTVBNOW 含有熱門話題，最新最快電視，軟體，遊戲，電影，動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。' `. G9 [( U# B- q% o$ {
5.39.217.77:8898% q6 t9 j/ o$ \& a& F
And please, if you're going to do period drama, make sure you get some of the historical background right - I'm not even talking about trivial details like using a genuine classic car from the period or getting the props 100% period-correct, I know TVB can't afford them, but just little things that are nonetheless important - like the other show about Wong Fei Hung for instance: the Chinese capital at the time was Nanjing. There's a reason they renamed Beijing (Peking) to Beiping - because Beijing wasn't a "Jing" (capital city) anymore - this is not a trivial mistake that can be overlooked. It these small, but important details that showed how ignorant the scriptwriter is (didn't pay attention in school? seriously, what qualifications does one need to become a scriptwriter for TVB, a simple literacy test?) and helped me decide whether a show is still worth watching or not - and totally inexcusable in this day and age given how easy it is to obtain information, you could say perhaps the general audience probably doesn't know either, but that says more about a decline in the quality of education in the general populace as a whole.
9 ?& ^/ h; E/ \& t/ e8 Z/ o& W+ l1 Y5.39.217.77:8898tvb now,tvbnow,bttvb, p. `( y' x0 Q5 {( k7 w5 T- L" i  }
Obviously I don't HAVE to watch TVB - but I do find it very frustrating that the quality of television has been on a gradual decline since the golden age of the late 70s. The technology was basic then, they still had to use film (not tape) to shoot outdoor scenes, the sets were nowhere near as elaborate as what we see today, but you can tell the people who produced shows from 網中人 to small productions liek the 10-ep 執到寶 really did put their hearts into producing shows that are truly entertaining, with a decent script and good dialogue to boot. These days, you just get the same CGI overkill, mediocre acting from last years beauty pageant, and predictable plot that you'll have no trouble keeping up with even if you miss a few episodes. It's all because TVB knows they can get away with making crap, because most of the viewing public can't tell the difference, or don't know any better.

harima

同意,背景也不是很重要,重要的是大家看得開心~

amypochacco

well said superbasara!!!!!!!!

estellacheng

呢套戲唔係大制作，係咁上下。